top of page

Before "Likes": Sport, Presence and Mental Health

7 hours ago
5 min read

As a former canoe-kayak athlete who grew up in the years before social media, I reflect on what sport has gained, and what it risks losing, by chasing “likes”. Of my European finals, in 2010-12, only a handful of photos remain. And maybe, deep down, that’s okay.


I am Giovanna, a pharmacist driven by a deep passion for the pharmaceutical world, mental health, and healthcare communication (here are my previous ITM pieces on The Relative Energy Deficiency in Sport (REDS): The Illusion of Health, and The invisible challenge of cystic fibrosis).


For many years my life moved to the rhythm of a paddle in the water. I raced in canoe-kayak all the way to the Italian national team at the Under-23 European Championships in Moscow (Russia) in 2010, and in Montemor-o-Velho (Portugal) in 2012. Today I look at the world of sport with fresh eyes, and I see an extraordinary opportunity reshaping athletes’ lives: the way they communicate through the mobiles all of us carry in our pockets.


Still, I think that behind the lightness of a like, it can hide a serious question for the mental health of anyone who plays sport, especially the youngest: “Are we still able to stay in the present?”


When the Race Course Wasn't Live-Streamed

In 2010 the social media landscape was still taking shape: some platforms were reaching the peak of their global popularity (Facebook, Twitter and YouTube), while others were just taking their first steps (Instagram and WhatsApp) and weren’t yet the extension of the body they’ve since become. Of my training sessions and races, I’ve kept very few images, tucked away in a folder on my old computer. And yet the memories are vivid, almost physical.


I remember the dawn training sessions, when the smell of the sea mixed with the cold that nipped at my hands. Then the sun would arrive: the warmth on my skin drying the salt, my hair curling in the air, and that constant, wonderful post-training hunger that tasted of satisfaction and of real life. I remember the afternoon gym, the good kind of tiredness that makes you feel alive. I remember the off-the-charts heat of Moscow and the plates of rice and chicken. And the wind on the course in Portugal, which seemed to want to steal the boat out from under me.


But what I remember best isn’t even about competing or training: it’s the colours of the Summer and the laughter, the carefree feeling of the training camps in Trieste and Rome with my teammates, the full sense of simply being there. Not living under a constant media spotlight let us be present in each moment, with a clean focus and a lightness that today feels almost like a luxury. And I’ll admit one thing: even though I competed and won the national team jersey, I was a nobody next to my teammates - who went on to build incredible sporting careers - or the legendary athletes I grew up admiring. But that never really mattered. What I carry with me is the gratitude for the people who shared the journey with me: thank you, my travelling companions, for the unforgettable experiences we lived side by side.


Hand holds a Polaroid of kayakers racing on blue water, with four women in blue and one in red near a buoy marked 5.
Photo by Giovanna Zerial - Women’s U23 K4 500m race, Moscow (2010) - Front seat, big responsibility. As the stroke in the K4 kayak, I act as the team’s metronome: setting the cadence, managing race tactics, and keeping all four paddlers in perfect sync under maximum effort

What Social Media Has Given to Sport

Let me be clear: I’m not here to mourn a lost world and pretend everything was better back then. Social media has brought wonderful things, and it would be unfair to say otherwise.

 

It has given athletes visibility and a real chance to find sponsors - previously a rare occurrence, if not in the disciplines in the spotlight. I’m thinking of canoe-kayak: one of those “minor sports” that, without a showcase, stay invisible next to the giants of football or basketball. Today, a single video can spark a child’s curiosity and lead a whole family to discover a new world, to get moving, to give it a try.

 

And then there’s the side I love most: athletes as positive role models. Real people who show what a healthy lifestyle looks like: proper nutrition, movement as an antidote to a sedentary life and junk food. Ambassadors for social campaigns that reach places a poster never could. When I was the one competing, none of this existed: anyone who wanted to tell the story of a niche sport had to hope for a few lines in the local paper. Today all it takes is a phone and a good idea.


The Other Side of the Coin

Then, though, there’s the flip side. The one I know less as an athlete and more as an onlooker.


There’s the obsession with appearances, the need to show every moment of the day - not just training, but the coffee, the recovery, even sleep. There’s the trap of “everything has to be flawless”, the constant chase for likes and followers on Instagram and TikTok, which turns life into a stage with no intermission.


The paradox is almost cruel: the athlete becomes an influencer and, by dint of influencing, ends up being influenced by media success. Stress builds, performance anxiety shifts from the field to the screen, and competitive focus risks crumbling between one notification and the next.


And it’s not just my impression. A study of young competitive athletes (aged 12-27) tracked their smartphone use: more TikTok meant worse sleep, harder recovery and more stress, while - surprisingly -Instagram went hand in hand with a feeling of calm; the authors hypothesise that it may be used as a pastime tool or to maintain positive social connections, although they warn that excessive use can still become dysfunctional. So, it’s not only about how much we’re online, but which app we use and how. The same research struck me for another reason: the most vulnerable were the lower-level athletes, whose well-being drops as social media use rises, while for those competing at the top the link was weaker, sometimes even positive. The same minutes of scrolling weigh differently depending on who’s living them.


Competitive swimmer racing in an indoor pool, with Instagram-style phone overlay showing READY. SET. GO. and social stats.
Image generated by Artificial Intelligence (AI) - Conceptual representation of the athlete between athletic performance and digital presence

When Champions Remind Us They’re Human

Some of the greatest have said it out loud. In fact, Inspire the Mind has already discussed the mental health difficulties shared by gymnast Simon Biles, tennis player Naomi Osaka and swimmer Michael Phelps. Champions who, under media pressure, found the courage to ask for help.

 

Scientific reviews show, in fact, that elite athletes aren’t immune to anxiety and depression, and that vulnerability grows with injuries, career transitions and public scrutiny, social media included. Making it harder still is what researchers call a “risk culture”: showing you’re fragile is still mistaken for weakness, so many hide their struggles. That’s why, when champions like Biles, Osaka and Phelps choose to speak up, their gesture counts double.


Coming Back to the Present

I don’t think the answer is to switch everything off and go back to 2010. That world no longer exists, and I wouldn’t want it back entirely.


But I do think we can choose the place we give to the screen. Remind ourselves that a race is lived with the body, not with the number of views. That the value of a dawn training session doesn’t change if no one sees it. And that a carefree spirit is a form of mental health no algorithm will ever be able to give us.


Of my European finals, only a handful of photos remain, but the smells, the wind, the laughter remain. And if I had to choose what to take with me, I’d still choose the memories, not the likes.


This article has been sponsored by the Psychiatry Research Trust, who are dedicated to supporting young scientists in their groundbreaking research efforts within the field of mental health. If you wish to support their work, please consider donating. 



 

bottom of page