top of page

Charles Dickens & Christmas: The Neuroscience of Storytelling

4 hours ago
5 min read
“I will honour Christmas in my heart, and try to keep it all the year.”

Charles Dickens, A Christmas Carol (1843)


Sometimes in the streets of London, if you let your imagination wander, you can almost feel him. A young man in his mid-twenties, walking at night through the fog and the gaslight, absorbing the faces of the poor, the noise of the markets, the silence of the streets, carrying it all back to his desk to turn into something immortal. His name was Charles Dickens, and the house where he wrote Oliver Twist and Nicholas Nickleby still stands at 48 Doughty Street, Bloomsbury, a few minutes’ walk from where I live. Today, it is the Charles Dickens Museum. I pass it often, and every time I do, I see him: collar up, walking fast, already composing the next sentence in his head. Not yet the one above, on Christmas. That promise is still a few winters away, waiting for him somewhere in the fog. But he is walking towards it, and so, every December, are we.


Sunlit brick townhouse row with red doors and a Charles Dickens Museum sign beneath a leafy tree.
48 Doughty Street. Photo: Diana Py Velloso

He carried one certainty: that a story, told well enough, could change whoever read or heard it. And science may help explain how. Each year, one of his stories returns before all the others: A Christmas Carol.


A Christmas Carol. British Library
A Christmas Carol. British Library

A Christmas Carol is a short book, a ghost story that Dickens wrote in six weeks and published a few days before Christmas, on 19 December 1843. Times were hard in England: trade had slumped, work was scarce, bread was dear, and children laboured in mines and factories. Christmas itself was an old feast that had lost its shine. In an age when print was what the internet is to us, the book went viral: the first printing sold out within days; within three weeks there was a pirate edition, which Dickens stopped in court; and by February the story had been adapted for the stage eight times. It has never been out of print since.


Dickens did not invent Christmas, but he gave it much of its iconography: holly on the walls and snow on the rooftops, a family gathered round the Christmas table and, above all, charity. Nearly two centuries on, that is still the Christmas we see. Most writers leave us books. Dickens left us a Christmas.


The story begins on a freezing, foggy Christmas Eve in London, where an old man sits in his cold office. His name is Ebenezer Scrooge, and he is rich, mean and alone. He gives nothing to the poor, refuses to dine with his only nephew, and grudges his clerk, a gentle man with a large family and little to feed it, a single day off. When his nephew wishes him a merry Christmas, he answers: “Bah! Humbug!”


That night the ghost of his dead business partner comes to warn him, dragging the chain of cashboxes and ledgers he forged in life. Three spirits will follow, and they are Scrooge’s last chance.


The Ghost of Christmas Past takes him back to his youth: a boy left alone at school, a young woman who loved him until he loved money more. The Ghost of Christmas Present shows him the clerk’s home, poor and joyful, where one of the children, Tiny Tim, walks with a crutch and is not expected to live. The Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come never speaks. It shows him a dead man whom nobody mourns, and then the name on the gravestone: his own. On his knees, Scrooge makes a promise: to honour Christmas in his heart and try to keep it all the year.


He wakes in his bed. It is Christmas morning, and there is still time. He sends the biggest turkey in the shop to the clerk’s door, dines with his nephew, raises the clerk’s wages, and becomes a second father to Tiny Tim, who does not die. Ever afterwards, Dickens tells us, it was said of him that he knew how to keep Christmas well.


As a psychologist, I cannot help noticing how strange this transformation was. The spirits give Scrooge no psychotherapy and no medicine. They show him scenes, and he feels his way through them until he is another man. He is, in effect, an audience of one. And what stories do to readers and listeners is something science can now measure: in the mind, in the body and, over the years, in the length of a life.


A Sea of Agitated Faces

Dickens did not only write stories. He told them. Weeks after the Carol came out, fresh from speaking to crowds of thousands, he described to a friend what it was “to walk out of the room where one is shut up for so many hours of such a short life, into a sea of agitated faces”. A Christmas Carol was the first book he read in public, in Birmingham at Christmas 1853, and the one he chose for his last, in March 1870, three months before he died.


Dickens’s Dream, by Robert William Buss. Charles Dickens Museum
Dickens’s Dream, by Robert William Buss. Charles Dickens Museum

A Princeton study suggests what was happening in those halls. Using fMRI, which tracks brain activity, researchers scanned a storyteller and then, one by one, the listeners. The more closely each listener’s brain mirrored the storyteller’s, the more tightly the listeners’ brains clustered together, “like a shepherd guiding a group of sheep”. A sea of agitated faces, herded by a single voice.


In April 1858 he read the Carol aloud for the Hospital for Sick Children in Great Ormond Street, and the money helped the young hospital buy the house next door. He read to a paying audience, not at the bedsides. What a story does at a bedside, he could only imagine; a study in PNAS has measured it, with storytellers reading to children in intensive care. Oxytocin, the bonding hormone, rose. Cortisol, the stress hormone, fell, and the children reported less pain.


Three Spirits, One Network

The first spirit takes Scrooge into his past; the second, into the present as others live it; the third, into a future that may yet be averted. Neuroscientists describe a single brain network, the default network, that does the same three things: it remembers the past, reads other minds and imagines the future. A story heard or read, exercises all three at once. The boy Scrooge, left alone at school, had Ali Baba and Robinson Crusoe for company. The old man spends his evenings with his banker’s book.


The boy had the better habit. In a study of 10,243 children, a Cambridge-Fudan team found that those who had read for pleasure since early childhood had, by early adolescence, larger language-related brain regions, better memory and fewer signs of stress.


And Scrooge’s promise has a second clause: it lasts the whole year. In a Yale study of more than 3,600 older adults, those who read books had a 20% lower risk of dying over the next twelve years, even allowing for health, wealth and education. It is an association, not proof. But Scrooge, too, wakes to find that the time before him is his own.


What Imagination Can Do

Charles Dickens never heard the word oxytocin or saw a brain scan, but with the instinct of a great artist he imagined what the instruments would later measure.


His house still keeps Christmas. From 18 November it opens on Wednesday evenings, when Dickens’s great-great-great-granddaughter leads guests through the rooms and the pudding is carried in; and through December the Carol is performed where he lived. The door is open.


Every time I pass his home, I still see him out there, collar up against the fog, walking fast, thinking furiously, with half of London talking in his head. I know it is only imagination. But then again, so was everything he wrote, and look what imagination can do.

 

bottom of page